One way of examining the merits of a system of thinking is to ask, “who benefits?”
For a very current example, the supposition that a public health care option is socialism. This spin technique takes advantage of our cultural paranoia of socialism. Our fear of socialism is of course linked with our fear of communism, which evokes memories of the Cold War.
Pundits and politicians scare up socialism fears because it’s an easy and effective button to push. By pushing this button, they bypass meaningful dialogue and yet stay afloat politically.
Who benefits from this negative hype? Who benefits from the cultural fear surrounding even the word socialism?
In this case, Insurance Companies. Lobbyists. Politicians who will receive campaign backing from Insurance Companies.
I think any policy choices should be examined against what we hold valuable.
See now, here is where it comes down to the shared dream. Here is the place our personal beliefs effect everything, not only about what is important but about how things actually work.
Say, I believe that all people should be able to see a doctor when they are sick. Ok, time for the public option, then? Well, maybe.
Say I also have the belief that in our country, anyone who wanted to find work can find it, and buy their own health insurance. According to my belief, someone who doesn’t have health insurance is obviously not trying hard enough, so it’s not my problem that they can’t get it.
The issue I have with a notion like this is that it assumes an amount of independance that I don’t believe ever really exists. I don’t believe anyone is ever really self-made (unless they are a recluse in the woods). Generally, people are vulnerable to shifts in the economy, are dependant on the government for things like basic law enforcement, keeping the roads driveable and all sorts of other things. Every person who is a financial success had things turn in their favor, often starting with their birth into a white and/or affluent family. There are, also of course success stories of people who started poor and “made it” but, as exalted as these stories are in our culture, they are not the norm. Class mobility is both more rare and more difficult than it is believed to be in this country.
I feel these things are often underplayed in public discourse. “The American Dream” of making it big is still a major part of our cultural tapestry, while the truth is that middle class and poor families keep getting poorer as the rich keep getting richer. In any economic system, policy helps determine how the money moves. Right now, the equation is still tilted towards those who already have plenty.
Who benefits from the belief that anyone can make it on their own? It’s not too hard to see! Now, when will we begin to dream up a new dream?